My daughter insisted that I give this book 5 stars. She fell in love with it when she was 6. She thinks it is so funny and likes to "trick" our visitors into reading it to her. I also find her reading it to herself, which is great! I was a mystery reader at her school and brought this book. Her classmates were all laughing so hard at it and begged me to read it again. I ended up purchasing a copy for her teacher! My 4 year old loves it as well.